Mafia: Mirror Image

by Unknown

Back to The Real World.

kiriwe2009-04-07 17:32:14
QUOTE (Tekora @ Apr 7 2009, 01:23 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Actually, part of the reason Shiri is #1 on my suspects list is because he's NOT playing like he usually does. He's being very UN-Shiri-like. Which I interpret as a scum tell.


How is he being un-Shiri-like? His logic makes sense to me, at least.

Can you please lay it out for me?
kiriwe2009-04-07 18:11:43
I ask because his behaviour so far does not fall into line with what I've noticed as Shiri-scum tells, but if I'm missing something, please, enlighten me.
Unknown2009-04-07 18:24:10
Shiri is pretty obviously scum
kiriwe2009-04-07 18:26:22
Can you please tell me what exactly has led you to this conclusion?
I fail to see his scummy behaviour.
Zynna2009-04-07 18:33:35
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 7 2009, 01:24 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Shiri is pretty obviously scum


There is nothing 'obviously' about it. In fact, I fail to see scum behavior on his part. I DO, however, see lots of scum tells coming from you.
kiriwe2009-04-07 19:05:23
Bali, I saw you reading, and you have chosen not to answer. Is this your way of saying that you are just throwing an accusation at Shiri because you find him threatening?
Unknown2009-04-07 19:17:31
Haha.

Thats me multitasking between seven programs, two games, and an engineering project.

Anyway - I have stated why I think Shiri is scum. If you refuse to acknowledge my points laid out in my earlier posts, thats your prerogative. Why should I have to repeat myself over and over? I dont mean to pontificate but I've played hundreds of mafia games, and I'm telling you, I'm getting a strong scum vibe from Shiri. Some of his posts are so scummy its just lol-worthy.

If you think I am being scummy, you should be voting for me, end of story.
kiriwe2009-04-07 19:19:17
I personally never said that you were being scummy.

Also, from what I've read, you have not pointed at specific posts and said "This post here is scummy because"

You have just been pointing fingers and throwing around words that you don't know the definition of.
Unknown2009-04-07 19:20:56
kiriwe2009-04-07 19:28:49
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 7 2009, 12:43 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
1. My gut is telling me Shiri.
2. Shiri's current posting style reminds me of games when he was scum.
3. Shiri has been extremely defensive to posts directed at him.
4. Shiri implied that there was something wrong with me voting for him even though I said I thought he was scum on multiple occassions.
5. Shiri has OMGUS'd twice.

Thats why I insist.

Alright, quoting this, since this is your only post where you outline "reasons"

1. Gut. Is this the same reason the others are voting Shiri? Because Daganev died?
2. What is it about the posting style that reminds you of games when he was scum?
3. Considering people jumped on him right away, I don't blame him for being defensive. I would get defensive too, if I were in his position.
4. What?
5. This is the only thing I agree with right away. I noticed this too when I was reading the thread last night, and it did jump out at me.

I'm not particularly convinced of his scumminess or his townishness, I just want to understand your position better.
Reiha2009-04-07 19:33:27
QUOTE (Kiriwe y'Kaliath @ Apr 7 2009, 12:28 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Alright, quoting this, since this is your only post where you outline "reasons"

1. Gut. Is this the same reason the others are voting Shiri? Because Daganev died?
2. What is it about the posting style that reminds you of games when he was scum?
3. Considering people jumped on him right away, I don't blame him for being defensive. I would get defensive too, if I were in his position.
4. What?
5. This is the only thing I agree with right away. I noticed this too when I was reading the thread last night, and it did jump out at me.

I'm not particularly convinced of his scumminess or his townishness, I just want to understand your position better.

Posting style - just his attitude. In the one game where he was innocent (for a brief period) that I played with him, he seemed less... agressive. But now I'm getting suspicious of almost everybody here!
Fania2009-04-07 19:44:36
QUOTE (Reiha @ Apr 7 2009, 12:33 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Posting style - just his attitude. In the one game where he was innocent (for a brief period) that I played with him, he seemed less... agressive. But now I'm getting suspicious of almost everybody here!


You aren't paranoid...we are all really out to get you. You're actually the only non-imposter here! tongue.gif
Fania2009-04-07 19:51:02
Okay, purple? Seriously? It's burrowing into my brain! It makes me want to lynch Reiha! I have luff for you, Silfferas, but why? Excuse me while I go gouge my eyes out.
Fania2009-04-07 19:53:06
Bah, sorry for spelling your name wrong Silferras. < see pink? Much nice on the eyes. Although you probably wanted Reiha to be annoying purple, blah.
kiriwe2009-04-07 19:56:12
both colors = my eyes, they burn
Unknown2009-04-07 20:08:39
You seem adamant about defending Shiri, Kiriwe.

Why do you think he needs a defense? Are you his scum buddy?

The thick-headed defense is p. common scumtactic. Dont see what issue you're having with point 4. Also its kind of rude to say "throwing around words that you don't know the definition of." - Lolwhat?

I put together a reasonable list of ideas as to why I think Shiri is scum. I think a level-headed person will find them justifiable. Its alot better than just random /vote: santa/ - which some have done.

Unknown2009-04-07 20:10:39
Requesting votecount.
kiriwe2009-04-07 20:16:26
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 7 2009, 04:08 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
You seem adamant about defending Shiri, Kiriwe.

Why do you think he needs a defense? Are you his scum buddy?

The thick-headed defense is p. common scumtactic. Dont see what issue you're having with point 4. Also its kind of rude to say "throwing around words that you don't know the definition of." - Lolwhat?

I put together a reasonable list of ideas as to why I think Shiri is scum. I think a level-headed person will find them justifiable. Its alot better than just random /vote: santa/ - which some have done.


Um, I don't think he needs a defense? I'm just not yet convinced of his scumminess. From my (limited to be sure) experiences with Shiri, he gets a -lot- more aggressive, and rather patronizing when he is scum.

I totally agree with you. A random vote after many pages, and a discussion going on is totally unacceptable, and if you will read back a page or two to my first post, I mentioned that.

If I am not mistaken, we had two random votes after page 8. Dugan and Shamarah (I think it was Shamarah, I'm going to have to dig up the post)

Fania2009-04-07 20:25:24
QUOTE (Kiriwe y'Kaliath @ Apr 7 2009, 12:56 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
both colors = my eyes, they burn

Aye, but the pink a little less. I assume she needed a pinkish colour to match the jiggly puff.
Dugan2009-04-07 21:36:52
Shiri + Dag = Bromance.