Mafia: Mirror Image

by Unknown

Back to The Real World.

Fania2009-04-15 21:02:39
Can we pressure a role claim here before we go and kill Llandros. I'm sure he's not the only one left who's either an impostor or an SK
Reiha2009-04-15 21:04:13
QUOTE (Fania @ Apr 15 2009, 02:02 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Can we pressure a role claim here before we go and kill Llandros. I'm sure he's not the only one left who's either an impostor or an SK

I thought he claimed he was psyduck... or something... not sure.
Casilu2009-04-15 21:05:53
QUOTE (Reiha @ Apr 15 2009, 02:04 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I thought he claimed he was psyduck... or something... not sure.


Yeah, he did... like twice now.
Fania2009-04-15 21:07:34
I know that Llandros claimed, I'm not talking about him.
Casilu2009-04-15 21:08:27
QUOTE (Fania @ Apr 15 2009, 02:07 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I know that Llandros claimed, I'm not talking about him.


Seriously, who would you pressure a roleclaim on?
Llandros2009-04-15 21:09:01
I'm easily the least valuable townie, so it's not real loss, but you might want to flush our other suspects before you rush toward a night of certain death.
Fania2009-04-15 21:10:10
QUOTE (casilu @ Apr 15 2009, 02:08 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Seriously, who would you pressure a roleclaim on?


Seriously, someone who is acting scummy. Like say maybe Kiriwe. I'm open for other options.
Reiha2009-04-15 21:10:48
QUOTE (Llandros @ Apr 15 2009, 02:09 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I'm easily the least valuable townie, so it's not real loss, but you might want to flush our other suspects before you rush toward a night of certain death.

Each townie is valuable, abilities or not. Get rid of all the ones without abilities and you have no lynching force.
Llandros2009-04-15 21:22:51
QUOTE (Reiha @ Apr 15 2009, 05:10 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Each townie is valuable, abilities or not. Get rid of all the ones without abilities and you have no lynching force.

I'd really rather not get lynched but if you're going to kill a townie it might as well be me.

How about this, give it at least 48 hours to check out other people and circle the wagons before we go into night. If at that time you don't have any better leads then knock yourselves out. It would probably be a wise move anyway and you have a fall back lynch if you come up empty handed.
it would be a - win/minimal damage to town - situation
Casilu2009-04-15 21:29:04
Now, who would a bunch of random roleclaims benefit more? Town or scum. At this point, I think we have MAYBE one scum left and an SK. With Llandros's claim, I'm pretty certain he's the SK, why should we vote around more?
Fania2009-04-15 21:34:10
QUOTE (casilu @ Apr 15 2009, 02:29 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Now, who would a bunch of random roleclaims benefit more? Town or scum. At this point, I think we have MAYBE one scum left and an SK. With Llandros's claim, I'm pretty certain he's the SK, why should we vote around more?


So we can fine the actual scum instead of the SK. The SK may or may not be an impostor, so if we get rid of him, the scum can still kill.
Casilu2009-04-15 21:35:34
QUOTE (Fania @ Apr 15 2009, 02:34 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
So we can fine the actual scum instead of the SK. The SK may or may not be an impostor, so if we get rid of him, the scum can still kill.


I already know who they're going after tonight. Take out the SK, I'll look for the last imposter. You have to trust me, Fania.
Llandros2009-04-15 21:41:28
On the odd chance that you are wrong, and i can assure you that you are, it would still make more sense. I'm not suggesting a mass role claim but i don't see the reason not to keep looking around when you don't have a sure thing and you know that bad stuff will happen tonight.

Also, if i'm not the sk, and i'm not, then there will still be two killers out there. So your, "i know who the scum is going after" argument is half as helpful as you think it is.
The risks don't outweigh the possible benefits.
Casilu2009-04-15 21:45:44
QUOTE (Llandros @ Apr 15 2009, 02:41 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
On the odd chance that you are wrong, and i can assure you that you are, it would still make more sense. I'm not suggesting a mass role claim but i don't see the reason not to keep looking around when you don't have a sure thing and you know that bad stuff will happen tonight.

Also, if i'm not the sk, and i'm not, then there will still be two killers out there. So your, "i know who the scum is going after" argument is half as helpful as you think it is.
The risks don't outweigh the possible benefits.

Mr. Frank Rosenthorpe PLEASE SHUT UP!
Fania2009-04-15 21:46:58
QUOTE (casilu @ Apr 15 2009, 02:45 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>


I don't think I could have said it better myself!
Kiradawea2009-04-15 21:49:28
Personally, I see two people acting scummy.

Llandros. While I am unsure of the one reason, as it just seems too big of a blunder, his latest post seem very similar to other mafia posts I've seen, where the mafia member tries to stall out the time in hopes that a new band-wagon is going to form and draw the heat away from him or her.

Kiriwe. I'm a bit unsure because she plays very similar to how she did in SSB mafia, where she had a town role. However, she was way too quick to unvote for Shiri after the roleclaim. It was way too easy to deduce that the roleclaim was fake.

But... I think we can test that in time. For now, I am going to.

Vote: Llandros

And apologize for not talking much. I've been busy and ill.
Reiha2009-04-15 21:50:49
QUOTE (Llandros @ Apr 15 2009, 02:22 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I'd really rather not get lynched but if you're going to kill a townie it might as well be me.

How about this, give it at least 48 hours to check out other people and circle the wagons before we go into night. If at that time you don't have any better leads then knock yourselves out. It would probably be a wise move anyway and you have a fall back lynch if you come up empty handed.
it would be a - win/minimal damage to town - situation

So you want us to give you more time to take one of us out before we get you?
Casilu2009-04-15 21:51:35
QUOTE (Fania @ Apr 15 2009, 02:46 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I don't think I could have said it better myself!


Seriously, it's like a guy is tied to the post and is saying he'll make us kings.
Dugan2009-04-15 21:54:33
4. Fania
5. Rika
6. Reiha
7. Kiradawea (replaced Caerulo)
8. Casilu
9. Dugan
12. Kiriwe
13. Solanis
16. Llandros
17. Tekora

Given the list above, I would guesstimate that:

By voting patterns,
Kirwie - town
Rika - town
Tekora - town
By role,
Casilu - town.
Solanis - town.

That leaves, Fania, Reiha, Kira and Llandros (and me - but I am town).
Out of the four, I am suspicious of Kira and Llandros.

What is the current vote total?
Reiha2009-04-15 21:57:16
QUOTE (Dugan Diluculo @ Apr 15 2009, 02:54 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
4. Fania
5. Rika
6. Reiha
7. Kiradawea (replaced Caerulo)
8. Casilu
9. Dugan
12. Kiriwe
13. Solanis
16. Llandros
17. Tekora

Given the list above, I would guesstimate that:

By voting patterns,
Kirwie - town
Rika - town
Tekora - town
By role,
Casilu - town.
Solanis - town.

That leaves, Fania, Reiha, Kira and Llandros (and me - but I am town).
Out of the four, I am suspicious of Kira and Llandros.

What is the current vote total?

I voted for Myrkr and Shiri, I'll have you know...!