Mafia: Mirror Image

by Unknown

Back to The Real World.

Unknown2009-04-06 16:24:39
Pretty sure its Shiri.

Shiri2009-04-06 16:26:09
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 6 2009, 05:23 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
The real one is dead? Masons are usually a pair? Hello?


wtf.gif

Yes. So (let's assume it's, say, Squirtle) a scum fakeclaims squirtle. The real squirtle, who being a mason is still in the game, jumps out and claims, then we lynch the faker. How is this not obvious?
Unknown2009-04-06 16:26:29
Maybe algebra will help. Daganev is Mason A, and he has at least one partner. Let's call him Mason B. Now, if scum tries to claim as Mason, while Daganev may not be able to confirm that, Mason B will be able to.
Unknown2009-04-06 16:26:47
QUOTE
Erm, precisely because they are a pair, there will still be the other mason. If scum tries to claim as the other mason, there will still be the surviving real mason, no?


*brain fart*

I just woke up! Shutup!

Still. Shiri's playstyle thus far just reminds me of when he's played scum. *shrug*
Shiri2009-04-06 16:26:49
And if you're pretty sure it's me, then your voting me makes no sense.

Unvote. Vote: Balizar.
Unknown2009-04-06 16:28:23
I voted you my first post, silly.
Fania2009-04-06 16:28:56
QUOTE (Shiri @ Apr 6 2009, 09:26 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
wtf.gif

Yes. So (let's assume it's, say, Squirtle) a scum fakeclaims squirtle. The real squirtle, who being a mason is still in the game, jumps out and claims, then we lynch the faker. How is this not obvious?


So the rule is to always believe the second person?
Unknown2009-04-06 16:29:24
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 7 2009, 12:28 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I voted you my first post, silly.

I'm getting real confused here. Maybe you should drink that cup of coffee first.
Unknown2009-04-06 16:30:17
QUOTE
So the rule is to always believe the second person?


They could always kill the remaining masons then have the option to claim the mason pair later on in the game. But since they cant do that right now, its usually prudent to do that and test the claims.
Unknown2009-04-06 16:30:44
QUOTE (Fania @ Apr 7 2009, 12:28 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
So the rule is to always believe the second person?

Of course, we'll weigh the two roleclaims and lynch whoever is less consistent. However, even if we do lynch the real mason, there's no real loss as we lose a relatively-vanilla townie to kill a mafia scum. A very worthwhile trade.
Unknown2009-04-06 16:32:56
QUOTE
I'm getting real confused here. Maybe you should drink that cup of coffee first.


Post #71, Scyther boi

And yes. I'm going to go drink mai coffee. *sips*
Shiri2009-04-06 16:35:44
QUOTE (Fania @ Apr 6 2009, 05:28 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
So the rule is to always believe the second person?

Well...I would, normally, because why would a scum go out of their way to kill a mason when they know they'll be lynched the following morning?
Unknown2009-04-06 16:36:01
That was a psuedo OMGUS from Shiri btw. Not scummy at all. Derp.

wink.gif
Unknown2009-04-06 16:38:35
QUOTE (Shiri @ Apr 7 2009, 12:35 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Well...I would, normally, because why would a scum go out of their way to kill a mason when they know they'll be lynched the following morning?

Heh, I wished we did this in the Angels mafia. /sidetrack
Shiri2009-04-06 16:41:44
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 6 2009, 05:36 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
That was a psuedo OMGUS from Shiri btw. Not scummy at all. Derp.

wink.gif

Voting for people for using terrible scummy logic to try and get someone lynched is not "omgus." I guess that's what the "pseudo" is for. Voting someone does not make you immune to voting for them!
Unknown2009-04-06 16:43:27
I think we have a Mewtwo running around somewhere, if anyone's seen the Pokemon Movies. (Or am I alone on this one?)

The cloned Pokemon, to my knowledge, are:

1. Pikachu
2. Meowth
3. Bulbasaur
4. Charizard
5. Squirtle
6. Psyduck
7. Vulpix
8. Nidoqueen
9. Golduck
10. Tentacruel
11. Seadra
12. Gyrados
13. Vaporeon
14. Venusaur
15. Pidgeot
16. Sandslash
17. Hitmonlee
18. Rhyhorn
19. Scyther
20. Blastoise
21. Wigglytuff
22. Ninetales
23. Vileplume
24. Rapidash
25. Dewgong


Hopefully this list is somehow useful. Anyone throw in if I forgot someone.
Fania2009-04-06 16:44:53
QUOTE (Shiri @ Apr 6 2009, 09:35 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Well...I would, normally, because why would a scum go out of their way to kill a mason when they know they'll be lynched the following morning?


I guess I was thinking back to the last game, where Silfferas tried to out Jack as scum. So if she had claimed something other than arsonist, we may have not voted for her at all.
Shiri2009-04-06 16:45:17
I will note that there is only one pink pokemon there (I think), wigglytuff. Do we have one out there that isn't Reiha?
Shiri2009-04-06 16:45:43
QUOTE (Fania @ Apr 6 2009, 05:44 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I guess I was thinking back to the last game, where Silfferas tried to out Jack as scum. So if she had claimed something other than arsonist, we may have not voted for her at all.

That's totally different to claiming the same role and pokeman name.
Fania2009-04-06 16:48:53
QUOTE (Myrkr @ Apr 6 2009, 09:43 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I think we have a Mewtwo running around somewhere, if anyone's seen the Pokemon Movies. (Or am I alone on this one?)



Hopefully this list is somehow useful. Anyone throw in if I forgot someone.


They match up to what's on my list. I strongly believe there is a Mewtwo as well.