so it doesn't protect yourself?

How much do you want the scum to know about my abilities? I would think either way is too much information.

I'm trying to figure out if you are lying or not. It's an interesting and ballsy claim.

unless someone has info to say that you are lieing, I'm going to go back to my original hunch and vote silfferas

I don't know if I believe Sifferas' claim about forgetting us at this point. It's likely she's trying so hard to stay under the radar, that she actually did forget. When she did post she didn't state any new information, it's like she purposely restated information that everyone else had brought up.

Vote Silfferas

I'm tired so I wont be back for a while. I've got the day off, so I think I'm gonna go take a nap or somthin'.

Vote Count

"FAAAAAAAAAAAIN!" --Thoros

Fania - 6 (Aerotan, Shiri, Arix, Casilu, Rika, Kiriwe)
Silferras - 4 (Llandros, Rika, Daganev, Fania)
Zynna - 2 (Kiradawea, Solanis)

10 to lynch.

Well, since we haven't heard anything from Silferras of substance (at least of late) I'll pressure vote her.

I'm still dubious of Fania's claim because I don't think there would be two pro-town doctors, and we already know for sure the other doc was pro-town. But if it's improbable there is two, it's near impossible there would be three, so I don't want to risk lynching Fania yet.

Vote: Silferras

It's also a pretty convenient claim Fania made in that it (1) cannot be verified, as she says her targets wouldn't know they got a ring, and (2) the near impossibility of having 3 docs and the other doc is already dead, so no one to speak up and claim that role again too.

On the other hand, we know how is lieing if we don't find anyone else soon and she is still alive

Of course, now that you say that, they might just not target her to get us to lynch her and save them time. That plan is unreliable.

Anyway, I'm really not liking Fania's claim. She has the same ability as Myrkr, but better because it doesn't have the limit (she claims this isn't "1x bestow permanent night protection with the ring", but instead a normal doctor ability that you can target people with differently.) Come to think of it, not only does this not make sense with the ring-giving thing (you don't notice, and then it randomly comes back? Really?) but how does it protect them in the first place? If anything it seems like the target was more vulnerable than if they didn't have it. I realise Shamarah's setup is killing our ability to figure out roleclaims here, but should we really let all that go given how Raz's and Obama's abilities both make sense in their context of their characters (I wonder if Balizar would have gotten away if we'd bothered checking his stuff on wikipedia first, heh)? Does anyone else have anything that seems inappropriate for their character? (mine is fine)

There's also still the random aggro over VA to contend with, and general lurkiness...meh.

Well, I'm keeping my vote on her, but I'll switch to Silferras if needed.

err, more vulnerable if they had it...I mean, they had the invisibility thing, but everything was coming after them, including the ringwraiths that could see through it and stab you...idk

Notice I said "if we don't find anyone else"



Have you read the lord of the rings? Do you know what Frodo's ring is/does?

It makes sense just fine. But it's too much of a risk not to believe her. Which is fine. We can let someone go with a false claim for one day. Remember, there is more than one scum around.

I have read/watched it and know what it does.

Mrrh. Ok, Silf it is.

I'm not sure about the odds of there being two doctors...I suppose that, given the crazy ass rules, there COULD be two doctors...But as someone said it seems awfully convenient since we just lost the tracker, and with it one of the only ways to verify the claim...
Are there any other investigators who could look into it during the night, if we decide not to lynch her?

Unvote For now till we decide something =/

There is PROBABLY another investigator, but I'm not sure they should have to reveal themselves over it.

Ah, right.

I guess someone investigate tonight, see what comes up, don't say anything if she's town..?

But then, if she is a townie doctor, she's probably gonna get mafia'd anyway. If not tonight, then some other. Hrmm...wait a tic while I reread something.

I can't find mention of it, but Dag, can you do that thing again, or just the once?

I can't do the same thing twice. That would be way over powered if I could.

Ah well, was worth a shot, I guess.

Oh, heh, forgot to Vote: Silferras. If nothing else we'll get another roleclaim.

Damnit, I figured out a really reason Frodo was scummy but forgot it while coming to the thread. OTL.

I'm sure I had it, but Unvote Vote: Silferras.