Shiri2009-05-15 13:25:13
And she didn't say protected against all actions, which is definitely worth specifying when you say protect. I would probably have believed that since it could at least be a drawback if you do it wrong and block the cop/tracker/etc. as a townie power.
Furien2009-05-15 13:25:20
QUOTE (Shiri @ May 15 2009, 06:23 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
2nd most I think might be Llandros at this point since you & him would make two townie nightkill immunes (dubious) and we have yet to see or hear from anyone that could take advantage of his body yet.
Which is odd, since I doubt the scum are all religious entities, so if everyone was really pro-town you'd figure someone would speak up if their role functioned that way by now.
Shiri2009-05-15 13:30:21
Well, it's possible that it's only a scum that can benefit I guess, but if someone did get a superpower from Llandros' body one would expect them to come up with a modded version of it as their only claim (well, they won't now that I've said that, but before.) In any case, I think Fania's been acting scummier than Llandros and one of the remaining people (Daganev said 6 who haven't claimed? And there's probably an investigator in there somewhere) might turn up with something like that under pressure.
Llandros2009-05-15 14:06:40
By all means investegator me. I have a night kill defense that i had to construct the first night.
I didn't want to mention it but after it blocks a night kill i have to re-build it the following night and would be vulnerable again.
I didn't want to mention it but after it blocks a night kill i have to re-build it the following night and would be vulnerable again.
kiriwe2009-05-15 14:13:55
In the movie, and the books, Frodo never gives that ring to anybody. It's his duty to see it destroyed, and to not see it fall into the wrong hands.
My vote stays.
My vote stays.
Shiri2009-05-15 14:14:22
Well, you really should have mentioned that earlier, but ok that does help your case. I'm gonna go ahead and believe that for now.
Incidentally, if people want to go for a lurker rather than Fania because of the risk (I don't) I suggest Reiha, she's said nothing of any use all game.
Incidentally, if people want to go for a lurker rather than Fania because of the risk (I don't) I suggest Reiha, she's said nothing of any use all game.
Reiha2009-05-15 14:33:58
QUOTE (Shiri @ May 15 2009, 07:14 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Well, you really should have mentioned that earlier, but ok that does help your case. I'm gonna go ahead and believe that for now.
Incidentally, if people want to go for a lurker rather than Fania because of the risk (I don't) I suggest Reiha, she's said nothing of any use all game.
Incidentally, if people want to go for a lurker rather than Fania because of the risk (I don't) I suggest Reiha, she's said nothing of any use all game.
Everyone's saying the same over and over. Is there something new you'd like me to add?
kiriwe2009-05-15 14:35:06
QUOTE (Reiha @ May 15 2009, 10:33 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Everyone's saying the same over and over. Is there something new you'd like me to add?
yes please, your take on the same
Reiha2009-05-15 14:39:02
I agree or whatever or don't care.
I'm just bored because it seems like nobody has died since I last checked.
I'm just bored because it seems like nobody has died since I last checked.
Shiri2009-05-15 14:39:41
Regardless of what I want you to add, there's no way we can tell if you're scummy when you haven't said anything of any use at all, so you need to be lynched.
Daganev2009-05-15 14:43:35
How is frodo a more shaky claim than "illusionarySelf" which unlike any other claim so far, isn't a person or something that people outside of lusternia would know about?
Reiha2009-05-15 14:44:11
QUOTE (Shiri @ May 15 2009, 07:39 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Regardless of what I want you to add, there's no way we can tell if you're scummy when you haven't said anything of any use at all, so you need to be lynched.
You want me to roleclaim or something? And I'm sure there are bigger lurkers...
You and Kiriwe just have a vendetta against me and my amazing track record that you guys put a dent in. >:I
Shiri2009-05-15 14:49:47
QUOTE (daganev @ May 15 2009, 03:43 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
How is frodo a more shaky claim than "illusionarySelf" which unlike any other claim so far, isn't a person or something that people outside of lusternia would know about?
An electron isn't a person either. The last one is completely arb and I doubt that's what he had in mind. The reason it's less shaky is that its ability is slightly more consistent with the role. Fania's is like completely perpendicular to what you'd expect, plus it's doubling up on an existing dead role. I'm wondering if you didn't get culted or something, I'd've thought you'd be on board with this.
Reiha, there are no bigger lurkers because you haven't been of ANY USE so at best there can only be equal ones. Aerotan has Daganev's support for some reason so since I can't be bothered struggling with that yet when you're just as good a choice, you're the next target!
Unknown2009-05-15 14:50:22
I don't have any say in what went into my role PM! And, well, we have an electron running around supposedly being vanilla, I'm not sure we can pose any restrictions on what can or cannot be roles in this game.
That said, I would like to see Reiha actually contribute to the discussion rather than going off on tangents and being defensive about not contributing, which isn't helpful at all to the town.
That said, I would like to see Reiha actually contribute to the discussion rather than going off on tangents and being defensive about not contributing, which isn't helpful at all to the town.
Daganev2009-05-15 14:50:32
QUOTE (Reiha @ May 15 2009, 07:39 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I agree or whatever or don't care.
I'm just bored because it seems like nobody has died since I last checked.
I'm just bored because it seems like nobody has died since I last checked.
Ok.
This will go with my plan nicely. If Reiha has a good claim, then we can look at all the current claims and see what makes sense and what doesn't.
unvote, vote Reiha
Daganev2009-05-15 14:51:38
The only other bigger lurker is Serrella.
Reiha2009-05-15 14:53:12
Myrkr + Balizar + Reiha = bad course of action.
Lot less useful than them, though. Town and I'm a beaver trapper.
Lot less useful than them, though. Town and I'm a beaver trapper.
Reiha2009-05-15 14:53:53
QUOTE (Silferras @ May 15 2009, 07:50 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
That said, I would like to see Reiha actually contribute to the discussion rather than going off on tangents and being defensive about not contributing, which isn't helpful at all to the town.
Why should I contribute if I have nothing to add?
Daganev2009-05-15 14:55:59
Firstly, Frodo's roll makes perfect sense to me. (the cult thing does not, turning invisible does)
If Fania, is a cult leaer, we will know when we lynch reiha, because Fania said she gave the ring to Reiha.
While the electron is not a person, it is something that people out side of lusternia would know about. So far everything has been realworld oriented. I'm sorry, but IllusionSelf doesn't sound very PopCulture like to me. (electron may not either, but if thats the case it should be a choice between the electron and illusionarySelf, not Frodo and illusionary self.)
We didn't believe myrkr's claim as doctor, and I don't want to risk killing off another doctor. I mean really, whats the connection between "hope" and doctor? It's very flimsy. Plus, claiming to have nightkill defences is a clasic scum fake roleclaim. Doctor isn't.
If Fania, is a cult leaer, we will know when we lynch reiha, because Fania said she gave the ring to Reiha.
While the electron is not a person, it is something that people out side of lusternia would know about. So far everything has been realworld oriented. I'm sorry, but IllusionSelf doesn't sound very PopCulture like to me. (electron may not either, but if thats the case it should be a choice between the electron and illusionarySelf, not Frodo and illusionary self.)
We didn't believe myrkr's claim as doctor, and I don't want to risk killing off another doctor. I mean really, whats the connection between "hope" and doctor? It's very flimsy. Plus, claiming to have nightkill defences is a clasic scum fake roleclaim. Doctor isn't.
Shiri2009-05-15 14:58:23
Oh I forgot she's even playing. (I also forgot Reiha's playing but saw her on the list.)
Unvote, Vote: Reiha
Unvote, Vote: Reiha