Daganev2009-05-20 17:56:09
QUOTE (Kiradawea @ May 20 2009, 08:18 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
How do we know that there are two killers? So far there have only been one person killed each night, and while Dia were supposedly killed by two things... well seeing that the kill-flavour is apparently random that doesn't give us much to go with.
The chosen victims also don't make much sense to me. I guess Dia seemed like a good choice due to her hinting at her heretic ability, but why Esano and Casilu? Casilu's power was shown to be almost perfectly worthless and she could easily have been mistaken for a scum. And Esano was just silent. Why not choose someone more active? I can understand not choosing me or Solanis since it'll prove that the other person is town, but why did no one go for Kiriwe, Daganev or Silferras earlier? Why go for Esano of all possible choices? Silferras, your ability. Do you know when someone targets you and you redirect the kill?
The chosen victims also don't make much sense to me. I guess Dia seemed like a good choice due to her hinting at her heretic ability, but why Esano and Casilu? Casilu's power was shown to be almost perfectly worthless and she could easily have been mistaken for a scum. And Esano was just silent. Why not choose someone more active? I can understand not choosing me or Solanis since it'll prove that the other person is town, but why did no one go for Kiriwe, Daganev or Silferras earlier? Why go for Esano of all possible choices? Silferras, your ability. Do you know when someone targets you and you redirect the kill?
I suspect that the mafia were hunting for the investigator when they killed esano, and casilu implied that he could force the scum to out themselves.
Fania2009-05-20 18:17:58
I just noticed something you said Dag (didn't want to quote the entire post...) Serrela isn't the only roleblocker, Kiriwe role blocked twice, once for me, and once for someone else...I think it was Zynna, but I can't find the post. So a semi role blocker anyways, because she can't do it anymore and had other skills.
Daganev2009-05-20 18:48:29
QUOTE (Fania @ May 20 2009, 11:17 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I just noticed something you said Dag (didn't want to quote the entire post...) Serrela isn't the only roleblocker, Kiriwe role blocked twice, once for me, and once for someone else...I think it was Zynna, but I can't find the post. So a semi role blocker anyways, because she can't do it anymore and had other skills.
Yeah, I moved Casilu and Kiriwe away from being in multiple categories, and put them into the category of "many one shot powers" because I noticed not just one person had that ability.
Fania2009-05-20 19:19:48
QUOTE (daganev @ May 20 2009, 08:03 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Serrela (for the odd role, plus, when I had my power I figured whomever the roleblocker was would be scum, because there would be no reason to roleblock night one unless you were scum.. also Serrela appears to be the only roleblocker, and that seems wierd to me.)
I just meant you put Serrella down for being scummy partially because there were no other role blockers. It is a strange role, though. Cats are evil, so it would be pretty funny if we find out she is Shamarah's Cat and scum.
Daganev2009-05-20 19:59:46
QUOTE (Fania @ May 20 2009, 12:19 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I just meant you put Serrella down for being scummy partially because there were no other role blockers. It is a strange role, though. Cats are evil, so it would be pretty funny if we find out she is Shamarah's Cat and scum.
Right, because she is the only person who is only a roleblocker.
Every other position has more than one person in that typical role, not including the people who have lots of one shot powers.
Fania2009-05-20 20:13:36
QUOTE (daganev @ May 20 2009, 12:59 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Right, because she is the only person who is only a roleblocker.
Every other position has more than one person in that typical role, not including the people who have lots of one shot powers.
Every other position has more than one person in that typical role, not including the people who have lots of one shot powers.
Got ya.
I was hoping we'd hear more from Furien, Shaddus and Serella. I want to figure this out before we end up in a no lynch or a random mod kill (dunno if Shamarah would do either). Do Shaddus and Serella even remember they are still playing? There are too many people sitting on the sideline right now.
Shaddus2009-05-20 23:25:03
QUOTE (Fania @ May 20 2009, 03:13 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Got ya.
I was hoping we'd hear more from Furien, Shaddus and Serella. I want to figure this out before we end up in a no lynch or a random mod kill (dunno if Shamarah would do either). Do Shaddus and Serella even remember they are still playing? There are too many people sitting on the sideline right now.
I was hoping we'd hear more from Furien, Shaddus and Serella. I want to figure this out before we end up in a no lynch or a random mod kill (dunno if Shamarah would do either). Do Shaddus and Serella even remember they are still playing? There are too many people sitting on the sideline right now.
Yes. But the lack of things that make sense, and the fact that I've had to work here and there to make spare cash, haven't given me the usual amount of time on the pc.
Furien2009-05-20 23:57:38
QUOTE (Fania @ May 20 2009, 01:13 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Got ya.
I was hoping we'd hear more from Furien, Shaddus and Serella. I want to figure this out before we end up in a no lynch or a random mod kill (dunno if Shamarah would do either). Do Shaddus and Serella even remember they are still playing? There are too many people sitting on the sideline right now.
I was hoping we'd hear more from Furien, Shaddus and Serella. I want to figure this out before we end up in a no lynch or a random mod kill (dunno if Shamarah would do either). Do Shaddus and Serella even remember they are still playing? There are too many people sitting on the sideline right now.
Serella may have had to drop out of the game, since she's working on finals.
Also, what else am I supposed to say?
kiriwe2009-05-21 00:10:56
Vote: Furien
I've noticed a pattern, and it is telling me that Furien is scum. And this is based on more than just guessing cuz of a a role or kill.
I've noticed a pattern, and it is telling me that Furien is scum. And this is based on more than just guessing cuz of a a role or kill.
Serella2009-05-21 00:49:51
Yup, I do have finals and may not be able to check the thread regularly. I'd like to keep playing, but if my absence starts to get in the way of the game, I don't mind being replaced.
Daganev2009-05-21 01:41:15
QUOTE (Kiriwe y'Kaliath @ May 20 2009, 05:10 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Vote: Furien
I've noticed a pattern, and it is telling me that Furien is scum. And this is based on more than just guessing cuz of a a role or kill.
I've noticed a pattern, and it is telling me that Furien is scum. And this is based on more than just guessing cuz of a a role or kill.
Do you mind explaining the pattern so that others can feel confident about the vote as well?
kiriwe2009-05-21 02:08:37
well, it;s not so much a pattern as she's willing to jump on vote trains willy nilly with little to no explanation, as well as a couple of people I've got my eye on, who also jump trains a lot, have not voted for.
Unknown2009-05-21 04:08:11
Which couple of people do you mean? I'd like some evidence as to this pattern you've seen as well, since I think Furien looks scummy because of his weirdly-worded claim and not his voting.
Anyway, Furien's two away now, so we need to come to some sort of consensus - unless he has something to add?
Anyway, Furien's two away now, so we need to come to some sort of consensus - unless he has something to add?
Fania2009-05-21 04:21:01
Furien is here. There is no reason why we can't give him a few minutes to post.
kiriwe2009-05-21 04:48:00
Both Aerotan and Llandros have stated that they weren't sure where they wanted to place their votes, then voted for people, then when the train started on Furien, both of them have declined to vote for her.
And both of them have been voting during the whole game, and have been pretty wishy washy from what I can recall.
Aerotan even suggested a no-lynch with a train this far along on Furien!
And both of them have been voting during the whole game, and have been pretty wishy washy from what I can recall.
Aerotan even suggested a no-lynch with a train this far along on Furien!
Unknown2009-05-21 05:00:06
QUOTE (Silferras @ May 21 2009, 02:08 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Anyway, Furien's two away now, so we need to come to some sort of consensus - unless he has something to add?
Consensus? I'd assume the people who are voting Furien want to lynch him/her so.... if we reach a lynch then it's a consensus!
He's apparently vanilla, he can't add anything else.
LETS LYNCH FURIEN GOGOGO
Aerotan2009-05-21 05:09:13
I already said, I'm wishy-washy on general >.>
I thought I had voted for Furien at least some point in the past, but looking back, I can't find it. And I realize that there's a decent camp on Furien, but as I recall there weren't many reasons given for the...er..reasoning.
And between Daganev giving me whiplash and the fact that every time I try to contribute, even if it's just to put pressure on someone, I start catching flack for it, I'm just not sure what to do.
We've lynched a townie every day. We lost THREE one day, and that was just during the day. And yesterday was so short the sun must've had a doctor's appointment or something, so forgive me for being hesitant at this stage.
I thought I had voted for Furien at least some point in the past, but looking back, I can't find it. And I realize that there's a decent camp on Furien, but as I recall there weren't many reasons given for the...er..reasoning.
And between Daganev giving me whiplash and the fact that every time I try to contribute, even if it's just to put pressure on someone, I start catching flack for it, I'm just not sure what to do.
We've lynched a townie every day. We lost THREE one day, and that was just during the day. And yesterday was so short the sun must've had a doctor's appointment or something, so forgive me for being hesitant at this stage.
kiriwe2009-05-21 05:19:11
would you quit complaining about the length of the day?
you weren't playing last game when we literally had a 45 minute day.
you weren't playing last game when we literally had a 45 minute day.
kiriwe2009-05-21 05:20:57
Aerotan, saying you are wishy washy is not helpful to you at all. I find it extremely telling that you wont bandwagon this time when you have in the past.
kiriwe2009-05-21 05:21:45
and with that, I sleep
see yall later
see yall later
