Guess I should say it, now that I've botched things... My role does specify that I win with the town. I don't want to give a roleclaim so early, but this is true.

Sorry if I'm playing really badly or something, I feel such a noob now :/

It took you 18 minutes to come up with "I win with town", seriously?

This game is kinda confusing

Looks like 20 minutes to come back to the thread to me.

Something about Serella is not sitting well with me

UNVOTE
VOTE SERELLA

I don't know what to make of this mess.
Anyone with a daykill want to take her out so we can get on with our search?

actually scratch that
a lynch is simpler at this point.

unvote vote serella

WHAT?

It's like you know she's not going to be the target of our search, but you still think she should be killed off...

The fact that you changed your mind just a few seconds later doesn't change the verbage you used here...

fat FOS on llandros.

Just to rephrase cause that might have come out wrong but...

When I read "Anyone with a daykill want to take her out so we can get on with our search?"

What I see is: "I know she isn't really scum, but she might be something, so lets kill her off before people get sidetracked from going after the main target."

Not a very townie friendly line of thinking.

Uhm. I understand that my semi-roleclaim must have seemed odd, but I honestly am town and probably not the most worthwhile target for a lynch. If you really believe that I'm suspicious, it might be better to find someone to investigate instead of wasting a daykill.

And yeah, it did took me 20 minutes to get back to the thread.

Casilu (for using an unknown power right away), Serella (for not knowing about town), and Llandros (because I agree with Daganev that it seems weird to demand a daykill) are my top 3 suspects.

I have a very small FOS on Kira because she has suspicions about Myrkr that she's not sharing, but there could be a good reason for not yet sharing, plus I enjoy her posts right now too much to want her killed off yet.

btw... I can't think of any role or something similiar that would say something along the lines of "You are group x, but a town faction also exists" So in other words I pretty much believe Serrela at this point.

So my top 3 are Llandros, Casilu (however she did the same thing last game when she was a medic), and Shiri for only voting for Casilu after others did, even though he posted sooner. (not to mention the other obvious reason that people should know better by now)

What did Casilu do the same as when she was a medic? All she did that game day 1 was complain about the cop dying night 1 (which I also would have done, as I pointed out) and then get defensive when you and Balizar jumped on her for it claiming it was a scum tell.

I majorly don't like "daykill Serella so we can get on with things." Without asking her to roleclaim or anything either, it sounds like a really bad attempt to fish for a dayvig while getting a random harmless out of the way.

Unvote, Vote: Llandros.

There aren't many I could think of either. Only one that comes to mind would be if she somehow had the ability to convert people to her faction, like Bowser in Myrkr's SMRPG game... And it seems a stretch for it to refer to town.

Daganev has a point. Llandros may know Serella isn't scum, and is trying to knock her out early. Less targets for his scummy buddies?

UNVOTE, VOTE:Llandros

Eh, I'm not entirely convinced, but I'll UNVOTE, FOS: Llandros

I'm going to unvote, and vote llandros mostly because that was a very quick switch from a daykill request to a vote. I want to go read what Casilu said, though.

Unvote for now.

Llandros did do something scummy, and while I can hope he's not scum, he just may be.

Vote: Llandros

Vote Count

"Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn." --H. P. Lovecraft, "The Call of Cthulhu"

Llandros - 5 (Shiri, Shaddus, Aerotan, Arix, Myrkr)
Shiri - 2 (Diamondais, Daganev)
Casilu - 1 (Zynna)
Silferras - 1 (Casilu)
Zynna - 1 (Furien)
Myrkr - 1 (Aerotan)
Kiriwe - 1 (Rika)
Serella - 1 (Llandros)

11 to lynch.

Ok, I first suggested to daykill Serella because there really isn't anyway to move forward against the 'oops silly me' defense at this point. I honestly have no idea if she is scum or not but she has the makings of an exceptional red-herring. Sooooo, that's where the bump her off and lets keep going thought came from.
If you look at the time stamps you can see that it took me only a few seconds to realize that at this point in the game that wasn't the best move. Also, it would have exposed whoever used the day-kill power so i thought better of it and decided a more measured approach would be better.