It was Silferras, why?

Because now I can figure out who you're claiming your role is supposed to be...but there is only one investigator that you could reasonably be a backup to in that scenario, and that investigator can only have one backup, meaning either Llandros or Dugan has to go.

That is, if we believe you, which is by no means a given, particularly with the horrible flailing going on all over the last couple pages.

Now that I think of it, you might figure out either Llandros' or Dugan's rolename instead of mine.

Damnit!
I hate it when people i'm hoping are scum say things that make sense. Also, after some research, it's possible that there could be two back up cops.

As a completely unrelated parable, the anime Death note has a genius detective hero that is killed and followed up by his successor who turns out to be one of two people said hero mentored.

Please disreagard my comments about siam, and cary on looking at people who are not him, shaddus or me

Yeah. The other one, incidentally, flips out and uh. Kidnaps someone...launches a rocket...I forget what happened after that but he made a pretty crappy policeman. So I'm not sure letting you two go would be wise! There are still too many investigators.

Wait, plus if you were trying to hint that you were the other one being roleblocked wouldn't have come up earlier.

BZZT.

unvote Vote: Llandros (if I have this the wrong way around, going back to Siam after, but he has more evidence on his side than you do)

Something I want to know about Llandros, now that he's come under suspicion, is how he knew that I'd been boosted night before last.

Has it ever occured to you though that having more investigators serves a purpose? We haven't killed a scum yet, not a single one and I'm confused why you're too intent on people whose likelihood of being an investigator is high instead of looking at other people.

I'm looking at you, Kira

FOS: KIRADAWEA

Four is still far, far too many (three is also likely too many, regardless of how unlucky, incompetent or roleblocked they may or may not have been.)

Because I've totally forgotten, what is wrong with Kiradawea again?

This is a big Mafia game, you've said this yourself and besides, it's Casilu, anything can happen.

On Kira, well, we haven't a clue on what she can actually do, though, and she has been too quiet. Disturbingly quiet.

Also, the list of players in the first page is horribly outdated.

I'm confused, Shiri. Why would Llandros being roleblock not come up?

Not good enough! One of those people is still very likely to be a scum.

Anyway, about Kira, I mean...we were on her earlier but her excuse was presumably good enough to get a reprieve, only I've totally forgotten what it was. Rika is in a similar boat, and Shaddus, and I think Sabres, so I'm just wondering why you named Kira specifically.

In fact, I do remember why we stopped going after Rika: your abortive investigation post. Clearly that is not good enough and we should reconsider that route, but in any case rather than either Kira or Rika I would rather figure out which of these investigators is legit and which are not.

(Casilu please update the first page )

Because the hint we were clearly supposed to take was about BACKUP cops, i.e they don't get their powers until the cops dies.

It was just deduction based on you saying that you were from bleach, not secret info.

Ok first off, stop tying to lynch me!

Second, i don't follow this argument. I was roleblocked the first two nights and said as much.

From Siam's claims, i would guess that he is Near, but of course he can't confirm this. I have reason to belive that shaddus is Mello and that it is likely he is town. Even if they are back up cops, and i'm not sure that shaddus is, it would still mean that there were only a limited number with invetigative abilites at any one time.

*Please note that none of my comments should be interpreted that I have stated or implied that i have a role, a power, or that i am even playing this game.

Hmm. In that case, I'd like to point out that Dugan also claimed to know someone's win condition(Shamarah) I think. That would mean that Dugan -and- Llandros could investigate from the start, but Llandros claimed to have been roleblocked. The thing is I'm inclined to believe Llandros now because of his latest posts prior to this one. Either Dugan defended Shamarah because they were from the same group. You've also mentioned that dugan was acting less scummy among the four of us whom you listed(me,llandros,dugan and xavius), can you please restate why, again?

Let me find Dugan's post about Sham or if anyone can do it before I do, please do!

Ignoring your last line because it is worthless and we need to interpret you as having a role and power for this to make any sense at all:

So you're claiming to be L, and that Shaddus is Mello. Ok, that is my bad, I assumed you were trying to pass yourself off as Mello (Mello being scum in this scenario) and a backup cop to avoid suspicion and also avoid running into potential Near claims.

This does add up, but that actually makes FIVE investigators, if we include Xavius' "silferras did not target solanis" quantity, because Dugan has already been semi-proven to have powers and you and Siam are slightly starting to make sense now.

So I think we should go for Xavius or Shaddus - I realise you think it's likely that the latter is town, but without any explanation as to why I'm not convinced, five people - even staggered - is way too many, Shaddus has been lurky all game, and Mello could easily be a villain role.