Vote: Anumi

Pretty much you avoided voting on Furien when it was a obvious lynch of a mafia member. Instead you just recoiled and gave a FOS which does absolutely nothing. It just comes off as weak considering the circumstances and seems odd.

Ah, sonuva...

I tried to follow after BroadwayBlueShirt last night, but I ran into the masked guy at my door (or maybe someone else with a mask?), and he punched me the out. Now I got a massive headache and no useful info.

I need to get going to work soon, so I'll be back later for discussion then.

Damn.

Well folks, that does it for me. Just remember the key is to pay attention not to WHAT people are saying, but HOW they're saying it.

Eh. As I said, I wanted to hear a little more discussion, I wasn't in a rush. Specifically Caerulo hadn't really posted anything and mentioned that he/she was going to come back and post more later. I didn't want to drop the hammer and end the day at least until then. Information is always a good thing, especially as we didn't get very much on Day One. So, barring an impending deadline, I want as much information as possible. ESPECIALLY as we had a solid lynch target lined up. I wanted to see who would defend him or make alternate arguments or whatever. Y'know, information.

And then you went ahead and dropped said hammer before Caerulo could come back to post anything and before any other potential scum could have any additional rope to hang themselves with.

Seems to me, an immediate lynch at that time had no upside. It was already pretty much a give that we were going to string up Furien, so why not, at the very least, wait to hear from everyone and try to see what else we can learn? What upside for the town was there in an immediate lynch?

Aw. We lost Jimi Hendrix?

Anyway, if we've a watcher who watched Vendetta it'd be nice for you to share what you know. Until then

Vote: Othero Yes, Anumi acted odd, odd enough that I probably would have vigged if I could, but such quick days are not good either. I personally wanted to hear what Caerulo had to say, and even though he was quiet, there hadn't even been 24 hours passed yet.

I'm making dinner and having dinner with my housemates tonight, so I'll be around later. Sorry guys.

I was waiting to see what/if Caerulo had to say. He and Othero seem suspicious to me for the reasons previously posted by Anumi. Going to give this a little more time to see if anything else interesting is posted and then I'll be back to vote.

Blast.

Caerulo posted that he was gone for 4 days and there was about 5 hours between his post and mine. He had room to post and being gone for 4 days I really really doubt he had any bombshell to bring us. And if he does he is still more then free to bring it to us. As for giving mafia room to hang itself, not going to happen. A smart mafia would clam up and we would sit there until someone just put the last vote on Furien. I'm not going to play with the idea that we got lucky and have a terribly dumb mafia that is going to go walk into the firing line for us.

Either way my lynch vote can not suddenly be turned around on me.

The Decemberists are the best band ever. Your taste in music pleases me.

The new album is great, different from what they had been doing. Closer to the old stuff. I guess it is the perfect middle ground of the two. I'm going to see them next week so I'm stupidly excited for the whole thing.

Man, I know. I downloaded it (entirely legally, I assure you!) about two weeks before it came out. You're a lucky bawstard for seeing 'em live, though.

Looking back at Caerulo's statement-in-question, he indicated a desire to read, but didn't specifically say he was planning to post. How much inference can you draw from that?

Not sure, I know I say it on occasion and totally forget to come back. Could easily be him keeping quiet though.

I never expected too much, nor did I necessarily expect a "bombshell". But absent a deadline, I didn't see any advantage to ending the day immediately. It's all information.

Smart scum tactic would've been to throw him under the bus, because it was obvious he was going to get lynched anyway. Delaying it, I think, is less scummy not more.

Othero protests too much. Vote: Othero

Hungover Votecount:
Anumi - 1 (Othero)
Othero - 2 (Gleip, Anumi)

With 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch!

Sorry, I'm gonna have to side with Othero on this one. I'm very much of the school that caution is a scum tell. (I was actually going to VOTE: ANUMI when the day started earlier, but I always seemed to put it off.)

Hmmm, that puts me at 2 votes away from a kill. Ok. I'm the Doors. My ability is the unknown soldier. Once a game I can day kill someone. If I don't use it today I pretty much can't use it unless a mafia member is lynched today. It won't end the day if I use it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0oW9GLgsa8s

But yeah. This game also seems to be slowing down so I'm very very close to using it as I'm very confident in who I think the rest of the mafia are.

Then go for it, if you're wrong though you would have to accept that we wont trust you after.