kiriwe2009-02-19 19:46:52
QUOTE (Tekora @ Feb 19 2009, 02:32 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
While we're waiting for Kiradawea to show up and modkill Fania for breaking the rules, I might as well share this just in case we get pushed into an early Night.
This is the second time S.A.W. has jumped on me for drastic moves. Now, maybe he's just a nervous-type player, but looking back at his posts, his logic seems VERY scummy.
No, your logic is looking more and more scummy, in my eyes.
In a game where we've had 7 roleclaims, 3 of them confirmed, this early in the game, any more roleclaims will help the Scum far more than they help the Town, because it gives the Scum more of an idea of who to target first.
Seven roleclaims? I don't remember seven, please list them. Also, there are 25 players, several of which we have heard nothing useful from.
This FoS came completely out of the blue while we were discussing Daganev's Maxim Tomato and while I was trying to build steam behind my Harkux train. Possible attempt to draw heat away from Harkux?
Not to mention that his next post continues to defend Harkux and push the Dag train forward. Again, I ask, more misleading?
And then again, he jumps on me for little reason other than me saying that Fania is a suspect of mine right now and that being on a team other than Daganev's would lead me to strongly believe that she is scum. Alas, this is all invalid now, as Fania seems headed towards a modkill. More interesting is the fact that Kiriwe, another top suspect, was all too eager to jump on and vote against me.
No, we are both questioning your logic for why Fania would be a suspect if Daganev is not on the same team as her. I didn't jump on you, I am following up on my earlier statement that I will not point fingers, I will vote my opinion, as I think this accomplishes more than just pointing fingers everywhere.
---------------
In all, if you were to ask me, I'd say that S.A.W. is really, really intimidated by me for some reason. I can only wonder why. Care to elaborate, S.A.W.?
FOS: S.A.W.
This is the second time S.A.W. has jumped on me for drastic moves. Now, maybe he's just a nervous-type player, but looking back at his posts, his logic seems VERY scummy.
No, your logic is looking more and more scummy, in my eyes.
In a game where we've had 7 roleclaims, 3 of them confirmed, this early in the game, any more roleclaims will help the Scum far more than they help the Town, because it gives the Scum more of an idea of who to target first.
Seven roleclaims? I don't remember seven, please list them. Also, there are 25 players, several of which we have heard nothing useful from.
This FoS came completely out of the blue while we were discussing Daganev's Maxim Tomato and while I was trying to build steam behind my Harkux train. Possible attempt to draw heat away from Harkux?
Not to mention that his next post continues to defend Harkux and push the Dag train forward. Again, I ask, more misleading?
And then again, he jumps on me for little reason other than me saying that Fania is a suspect of mine right now and that being on a team other than Daganev's would lead me to strongly believe that she is scum. Alas, this is all invalid now, as Fania seems headed towards a modkill. More interesting is the fact that Kiriwe, another top suspect, was all too eager to jump on and vote against me.
No, we are both questioning your logic for why Fania would be a suspect if Daganev is not on the same team as her. I didn't jump on you, I am following up on my earlier statement that I will not point fingers, I will vote my opinion, as I think this accomplishes more than just pointing fingers everywhere.
---------------
In all, if you were to ask me, I'd say that S.A.W. is really, really intimidated by me for some reason. I can only wonder why. Care to elaborate, S.A.W.?
FOS: S.A.W.
I didn't see his post when I posted my FOS post, because as soon as I saw your bizarre logic, I responded. He ninjaed me : )
Please, please explain to us why Fania is a suspect if Daganev isn't on her team. As I stated before, she would have to be impossibly stupid to be scum and not throw that team heal item at somebody else who is not scum. That's where my suspicion of you comes from.
Unknown2009-02-19 19:47:43
QUOTE (Tekora @ Feb 19 2009, 02:32 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
While we're waiting for Kiradawea to show up and modkill Fania for breaking the rules, I might as well share this just in case we get pushed into an early Night.
This is the second time S.A.W. has jumped on me for drastic moves. Now, maybe he's just a nervous-type player, but looking back at his posts, his logic seems VERY scummy.
In a game where we've had 7 roleclaims, 3 of them confirmed, this early in the game, any more roleclaims will help the Scum far more than they help the Town, because it gives the Scum more of an idea of who to target first.
This FoS came completely out of the blue while we were discussing Daganev's Maxim Tomato and while I was trying to build steam behind my Harkux train. Possible attempt to draw heat away from Harkux?
Not to mention that his next post continues to defend Harkux and push the Dag train forward. Again, I ask, more misleading?
And then again, he jumps on me for little reason other than me saying that Fania is a suspect of mine right now and that being on a team other than Daganev's would lead me to strongly believe that she is scum. Alas, this is all invalid now, as Fania seems headed towards a modkill. More interesting is the fact that Kiriwe, another top suspect, was all too eager to jump on and vote against me.
---------------
In all, if you were to ask me, I'd say that S.A.W. is really, really intimidated by me for some reason. I can only wonder why. Care to elaborate, S.A.W.?
FOS: S.A.W.
This is the second time S.A.W. has jumped on me for drastic moves. Now, maybe he's just a nervous-type player, but looking back at his posts, his logic seems VERY scummy.
In a game where we've had 7 roleclaims, 3 of them confirmed, this early in the game, any more roleclaims will help the Scum far more than they help the Town, because it gives the Scum more of an idea of who to target first.
This FoS came completely out of the blue while we were discussing Daganev's Maxim Tomato and while I was trying to build steam behind my Harkux train. Possible attempt to draw heat away from Harkux?
Not to mention that his next post continues to defend Harkux and push the Dag train forward. Again, I ask, more misleading?
And then again, he jumps on me for little reason other than me saying that Fania is a suspect of mine right now and that being on a team other than Daganev's would lead me to strongly believe that she is scum. Alas, this is all invalid now, as Fania seems headed towards a modkill. More interesting is the fact that Kiriwe, another top suspect, was all too eager to jump on and vote against me.
---------------
In all, if you were to ask me, I'd say that S.A.W. is really, really intimidated by me for some reason. I can only wonder why. Care to elaborate, S.A.W.?
FOS: S.A.W.
I'm not intimidated, I'm annoyed. You're telling people to shut up and get in line, and trying to rush night, which doesn't help the town really.
And wtf here. First you say "Oh man, he's against Dag but for Hark, since I suspect Hark, he must be scum too!" then you say "Oh double man! he's against Dag but for Fania, since I now suspect Fania, he must be scum three!" So basically you're saying that you've just found possibly the only 3 scum all stupid enough to jump to eachother's defenses? Or maybe I was simply thinking pressure on Dag would be a good idea? I was obviously very consistent in that.
You are super aggressive. I don't care for that at all. It's as simple as that. Consider it a difference in play-styles. I run on facts and analyzing things. Patience and facts. You run on instinct and emotion. We're polar opposite player-types, and that's fine, but don't crawl up on me just because of that.
Again, my reasoning for saying that roleclaims are not a bad tactic here is because it's the truth--in this sort of game, just like last game, the massive wave of roleclaims actually helped us. So I have a base for my beliefs. I'm playing the same way this game as I was last game, just as Shiri pointed out, and in that game I was essentially town.
So FOS me all you want, but to me it looks like nothing more than a tantrum because you're being called on BS logic. This may be mafia, but I'm not in support of the emotional mob mentality. Sorry.
Fania2009-02-19 19:55:08
QUOTE (Tekora @ Feb 19 2009, 11:32 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
While we're waiting for Kiradawea to show up and modkill Fania for breaking the rules, I might as well share this just in case we get pushed into an early Night.
I thought other people had basically quoted her already when they revealed what their items did. I thought the no quoting rule was meant for if you PMed someone else. It's my first time playing, so it's hard to know in what context to put all of the rules. I wont do it again and I hope she doesn't modkill me for this
Tekora2009-02-19 19:55:18
My logic for suspecting Fania is simple. I don't believe Daganev is scum. I believe Fania IS scum. If they're proven to be on different teams, then that will prove to me in my eyes that Fania IS scum. What I find funny is how much effort you just put into trying to discredit me and how easily I shrugged you off. Not to mention that anything involving Fania is soon to be rendered irrelevant, due to her imminent modkill.
Keep digging yourself deeper. Again, I find myself wishing that Shaddus had saved that day-kill. Now I'm going to wait until Kiradawea shows up and we find out what Fania's role is. Then we can see if you'll have to eat your words.
Keep digging yourself deeper. Again, I find myself wishing that Shaddus had saved that day-kill. Now I'm going to wait until Kiradawea shows up and we find out what Fania's role is. Then we can see if you'll have to eat your words.
kiriwe2009-02-19 19:58:56
QUOTE (Tekora @ Feb 19 2009, 02:55 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
My logic for suspecting Fania is simple. I don't believe Daganev is scum. I believe Fania IS scum. If they're proven to be on different teams, then that will prove to me in my eyes that Fania IS scum. What I find funny is how much effort you just put into trying to discredit me and how easily I shrugged you off. Not to mention that anything involving Fania is soon to be rendered irrelevant, due to her imminent modkill.
Keep digging yourself deeper. Again, I find myself wishing that Shaddus had saved that day-kill. Now I'm going to wait until Kiradawea shows up and we find out what Fania's role is. Then we can see if you'll have to eat your words.
Keep digging yourself deeper. Again, I find myself wishing that Shaddus had saved that day-kill. Now I'm going to wait until Kiradawea shows up and we find out what Fania's role is. Then we can see if you'll have to eat your words.
Tell me why scum would throw a TEAM HEAL item at not scum?
That's the part of your logic that is still wonky, regardless of whether or not somebody is new to playing.
kiriwe2009-02-19 20:00:35
and if I'm wrong, I'm wrong. Like I've said before, people make mistakes, especially when we are throwing wild accusations everywhere with little sound proof as a base to work off of.
Tekora2009-02-19 20:06:22
QUOTE (S.A.W. @ Feb 19 2009, 02:47 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I'm not intimidated, I'm annoyed. You're telling people to shut up and get in line, and trying to rush night, ((Night has gone on for 25 friggin pages, how much longer do you need it to go on? Besides long enough to grab up a few more roleclaims?)) which doesn't help the town really.
And wtf here. First you say "Oh man, he's against Dag but for Hark, since I suspect Hark, he must be scum too!" then you say "Oh double man! he's against Dag but for Fania, since I now suspect Fania, he must be scum three!" So basically you're saying that you've just found possibly the only 3 scum all stupid enough to jump to eachother's defenses? Or maybe I was simply thinking pressure on Dag would be a good idea? I was obviously very consistent in that.((I didn't suspect you at all until after your second attack on me, in fact, I still don't suspect you enough to change my Harkux vote. However, that doesn't change the fact that you're the only one who's tried to provoke action against me, even though I have support from several other players.))
You are super aggressive. I don't care for that at all. It's as simple as that. Consider it a difference in play-styles. I run on facts and analyzing things. Patience and facts. You run on instinct and emotion. We're polar opposite player-types, and that's fine, but don't crawl up on me just because of that. ((You're the one crawling up on me. My target is HARKUX, not you. I'm simply defending myself.))
Again, my reasoning for saying that roleclaims are not a bad tactic here is because it's the truth--in this sort of game, just like last game, the massive wave of roleclaims actually helped us. So I have a base for my beliefs. I'm playing the same way this game as I was last game, just as Shiri pointed out, and in that game I was essentially town. ((Who gives a flying hockey puck about what happened LAST game? I hate people that try and claim that because something happened last game, that it gives them some kind of credibility. It's transparent and it reeks of SCUM.))
So FOS me all you want, but to me it looks like nothing more than a tantrum because you're being called on BS logic. This may be mafia, but I'm not in support of the emotional mob mentality. Sorry, ((What BS logic? I explained above, Daganev's actions aren't scummy to me at the moment. Fania's actions are.))
And wtf here. First you say "Oh man, he's against Dag but for Hark, since I suspect Hark, he must be scum too!" then you say "Oh double man! he's against Dag but for Fania, since I now suspect Fania, he must be scum three!" So basically you're saying that you've just found possibly the only 3 scum all stupid enough to jump to eachother's defenses? Or maybe I was simply thinking pressure on Dag would be a good idea? I was obviously very consistent in that.((I didn't suspect you at all until after your second attack on me, in fact, I still don't suspect you enough to change my Harkux vote. However, that doesn't change the fact that you're the only one who's tried to provoke action against me, even though I have support from several other players.))
You are super aggressive. I don't care for that at all. It's as simple as that. Consider it a difference in play-styles. I run on facts and analyzing things. Patience and facts. You run on instinct and emotion. We're polar opposite player-types, and that's fine, but don't crawl up on me just because of that. ((You're the one crawling up on me. My target is HARKUX, not you. I'm simply defending myself.))
Again, my reasoning for saying that roleclaims are not a bad tactic here is because it's the truth--in this sort of game, just like last game, the massive wave of roleclaims actually helped us. So I have a base for my beliefs. I'm playing the same way this game as I was last game, just as Shiri pointed out, and in that game I was essentially town. ((Who gives a flying hockey puck about what happened LAST game? I hate people that try and claim that because something happened last game, that it gives them some kind of credibility. It's transparent and it reeks of SCUM.))
So FOS me all you want, but to me it looks like nothing more than a tantrum because you're being called on BS logic. This may be mafia, but I'm not in support of the emotional mob mentality. Sorry, ((What BS logic? I explained above, Daganev's actions aren't scummy to me at the moment. Fania's actions are.))
Fania2009-02-19 20:07:31
QUOTE (Tekora @ Feb 19 2009, 11:55 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
My logic for suspecting Fania is simple. I don't believe Daganev is scum. I believe Fania IS scum. If they're proven to be on different teams, then that will prove to me in my eyes that Fania IS scum. What I find funny is how much effort you just put into trying to discredit me and how easily I shrugged you off. Not to mention that anything involving Fania is soon to be rendered irrelevant, due to her imminent modkill.
Keep digging yourself deeper. Again, I find myself wishing that Shaddus had saved that day-kill. Now I'm going to wait until Kiradawea shows up and we find out what Fania's role is. Then we can see if you'll have to eat your words.
Keep digging yourself deeper. Again, I find myself wishing that Shaddus had saved that day-kill. Now I'm going to wait until Kiradawea shows up and we find out what Fania's role is. Then we can see if you'll have to eat your words.
Even if I do get modkilled it doesn't explain why you would think I was scum. You are defining me as scum because you believe that Daganev is not scum. I would have to be acting the opposite of Dag if I was scum and he wasn't. So show us where I'm acting like scum.
kiriwe2009-02-19 20:12:45
QUOTE
I didn't suspect you at all until after your second attack on me, in fact, I still don't suspect you enough to change my Harkux vote. However, that doesn't change the fact that you're the only one who's tried to provoke action against me, even though I have support from several other players.
Which several other players are you referring to?
Also, please list the seven roleclaims you mentioned.
Tekora2009-02-19 20:15:49
QUOTE (Kiriwe y'Kaliath @ Feb 19 2009, 02:58 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Tell me why scum would throw a TEAM HEAL item at not scum?
Because Fania screwed up. Pretty simple, eh?
QUOTE (Fania @ Feb 19 2009, 03:07 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Even if I do get modkilled it doesn't explain why you would think I was scum. You are defining me as scum because you believe that Daganev is not scum. I would have to be acting the opposite of Dag if I was scum and he wasn't. So show us where I'm acting like scum.
You voted No Lynch. Or did you forget? There's also this.
QUOTE
I think we are over thinking everything now. I don't know if the best plan is to lynch Harkux. I'll have to think about it more. Yes, I'm a hypocrite.
You've proven to me that you don't know heads from tails. So yes, I believe that Fania is fully capable of screwing up with the Team Healer, and I think that she's a newbie scum that's stumbled far too many times.
BUT ALL THIS IS NULL AND VOID BECAUSE FANIA IS DUE FOR A MODKILL.
Tekora2009-02-19 20:16:41
And for the damn roleclaims you keep asking for...
http://forums.lusternia.com/index.php?s=&a...st&p=618930
Learn to go back and read what's happened.
http://forums.lusternia.com/index.php?s=&a...st&p=618930
Learn to go back and read what's happened.
Narsrim2009-02-19 20:16:47
F.O.S. Tekora
I'm not a huge fan of the "cause I said so" logic. I'm not sure about Fania, but your explanations are weak at best.
I'm not a huge fan of the "cause I said so" logic. I'm not sure about Fania, but your explanations are weak at best.
Noola2009-02-19 20:18:02
How do you know the Mod'll kill her and not just give a strongly worded, "Don't do that!" warning, especially since she's a newbie and all.
Narsrim2009-02-19 20:19:06
QUOTE (Noola @ Feb 19 2009, 03:18 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
How do you know the Mod'll kill her and not just give a strongly worded, "Don't do that!" warning, especially since she's a newbie and all.
He doesn't, which I think is fishy as well.
Fania2009-02-19 20:20:11
QUOTE (Tekora @ Feb 19 2009, 12:15 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
BUT ALL THIS IS NULL AND VOID BECAUSE FANIA IS DUE FOR A MODKILL.
Maybe I am, but I think you should let Kiradawea decide that. It said in the rules that she can chose to decide to do so if she wanted. It did not say that she had to. She may show leniency because I'm a newbie. If not I'll accept it, but right now you are deciding for her.
Tekora2009-02-19 20:20:20
QUOTE (Noola @ Feb 19 2009, 03:18 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
How do you know the Mod'll kill her and not just give a strongly worded, "Don't do that!" warning, especially since she's a newbie and all.
Because if rules are given for a game, I'd expect those rules to be enforced.
Daganev2009-02-19 20:20:52
Tekora, I think you are barking up the wrong trees. What you have basically uncovered is the fact that if people talk long enough in a short amount of time their emotions will get the best of them in posts, and that those ideas and emotions will change with facts.
I think you want to look more closely at the people who have posted less than our mod has. (and I doubt Fania will be mod killed, but who knows!)
I think you want to look more closely at the people who have posted less than our mod has. (and I doubt Fania will be mod killed, but who knows!)
Tekora2009-02-19 20:21:03
QUOTE (Fania @ Feb 19 2009, 03:20 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Maybe I am, but I think you should let Kiradawea decide that. It said in the rules that she can chose to decide to do so if she wanted. It did not say that she had to. She may show leniency because I'm a newbie. If not I'll accept it, but right now you are deciding for her.
I'm not deciding anything, I'm expecting it. Stop putting words in my mouth.
Daganev2009-02-19 20:22:26
QUOTE (Tekora @ Feb 19 2009, 12:20 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Because if rules are given for a game, I'd expect those rules to be enforced.
The rules just gives her an option to mod kill people. Doesn't say 100% it will happen.
Noola2009-02-19 20:22:37
Tekora is so full of anger.